Horse -Geraldine Brooks

Interesting subject - some thought cliched, too many  and too many coincidences. More found it  readable and good.

She's better at historical than contemporary scenes.

The Stubborn Archivist - Yara Rorigues-Fowler

 Not hated  but not loved. Does the odd form ( some almost blank pages. seemingly unconnected jottings)help this readership of older white men understand a young mixed race woman's life? Not most of us...

Jacqueline Harpman -I who have never known Men

 A strange and strangely compelling book . Where , when and why is it set ? 

Jeanette Winterson - The Passion

 Passion- is it always unrequited?  Why the fantastical elements ? Is it written ( first person narrative)  by a mad man?   Some great passages ;and a good discussion ensued.

Alexander Lernet-Holenia --Count Luna

 A strange little volume . Is it parable of the "lunacy" of the Nazi regime? or just about a couple of odd people?  Quite interesting in its way,

Nussaibah Younis - Fundamentally

An interesting setting , about "ISIS brides". Some thought the jokiness detracted and were not convinced-others were more positive  

Aminata Forna The Hired Man

Set in Croatia . Who is good who is bad?   A good read overall